Hi to all Designers,

After reviewing all 342 designs, and then selecting the 20 then down to 5, our CEO has selected one design in particular, this was given 5 Stars, and all those not selected were given 3.

We thought this was the fairest way as 90% of the designs were very good, but then again some didnt completely read the brief, and many focused on the word PUNCH, where actually the keyword was PRO.

We Thank You all for your participation and wish you well for the future.

Regards,

Kevin.


----------------------------------------
Hi to all Designers,

Now we are upto 272 unique designs, the CEO has reviewed all and the decision has been made to grade those whom are still in the running to be chosen for the best designed logo.

To be fair to those whom submitted after the 20/04/2017 10:35:46, here is the notice I sent to all designers then.

There is no easy way to grade but whom receive 3 Stars will no longer be considered, those whom receive 4 Stars will still be in the running.

All submissions have been good, some standard out more than others, we wish all those whom didnt make this cut, all the best for the future.

Regards,

Kevin.


-------------------------
Hi to all Designers,

We never expected such an overwhelming response. So far 230 unique, designs have been submitted, which makes the selection process very hard and demanding.

While we do like varied approach, the CEO, after reviewing today so far, has indicated that the preference, is for clean sharp distinctive logo.

Our intended use for this app is at present for inhouse use on the many construction and engineering projects we have, but there maybe also be a commercial use, hence we have to do this process once and select the right logo.

His concern is around how many have taken the word PUNCH and have made logos with stylised fists, stars, boxing references, this doesnt portray what he is looking for.

So with this in mind, I have been instructed to reject those logo's that depict the points made above.

While we do acknowledge all the hard work put in by those designers, and some of the logo's that will be rejected are very good, but sadly dont reflect what we are looking for.

Thank You.

Kevin.
By You 20 Apr 2017 10:35:46
By You 21 Apr 2017 11:32:52